’30 Rock’ goes over the racial edge

Margaret Cho as 'Kim Jong-il

What I’ve loved about 30 Rock when it delves into racial territory is that it’s not afraid to go there. It’s not afraid to be offensive and gratifying at the same time. Liz’s classic white liberal racial fumbles (thinking her Arab neighbor was a terrorist, saying she voted for Barack Obama when she didn’t, her odd, tension-filled relationship with Wayne Brady) are hilarious and make viewers uncomfortable in a very realistic way.

In the past, a few critics have brought up issues they’ve had with Tracy Morgan’s character, Tracy Jordan, a spoiled, infantile man with a love of strip clubs and a penchant for over-enunciation. I’ve always justified Morgan’s character by saying that all characters on 30 Rock are crazy, and are occasionally exaggerated stereotypes, or purposeful un-stereotypes like John Cho in his brief, but hilarious cameo in one of my favorite episodes of the season, “Double-Edged Sword.”

So for the most part, as much as I’m torn between laughing at Sherri Shepherd’s loudmouthed depiction of Tracy Jordan’s wife, Angie, and cringing at all the stereotypes of the ‘sassy black woman’ she seems to be confirming, I remember that 30 Rock creates a weird, uncomfortable tension for everybody. Not even the gravelly-toned Jack Donaghy is safe from satire.

But this week’s episode of 30 Rock, “Everything Sunny All the Time Always” was not only subpar comedically speaking, but indulged in some major stereotyping that made me so uncomfortable, I’m wondering if it went too far.

In “Everything Sunny All the Time Always,” Jack Donaghy’s wife, Avery, is on assignment in Asia only to be captured by Kim Jong-il, played by Korean comedienne Margeret Cho, who it should be noted, has been criticized in the past for her stereotypical portrayals of her family members. ‘Kim Jong-il’ speaks horrible, broken English and is clearly supposed to be crazy. Stereotypical ‘Oriental’ music plays in the background as he talks about how he is the world’s best director and was best man at Tom Brady’s wedding. Cheap jokes about the country’s food production ensue.

Now Kim Jong-il has committed egregious crimes against humanity, but the way that 30 Rock lampoons him is steeped in such racialized baggage. Asian men have historically been depicted as asexual and effeminate. They’re also frequently portrayed as weird like Ken Jeong on Community. Many times it seems like the media uses awful dictators as an excuse to indulge in the worse kind of broad stereotyping. These dictators, often people of color in third world countries, are caricatured as crazy and irrational. Idi Amin was a savage black cannibal. Kim Jong-il is a crazy, effeminate weirdo. Hugo Chavez is a hotheaded, crazed commie.

Now I’m not denying that these people are, to put it very simply, bad. It’s common for American popular culture to satirize political figures from around the world, but the line between satirizing actual character traits and imagined, stereotypical ones is a thin line. Last night, 30 Rock crossed it.

The worst thing about painting world dictators as irrational/crazy/weird/effeminate/savage/hotheaded/heartless is that we cast them in a state of alterity. We distance ourselves, acting as if Americans are incapable of being cruel, of being savage, of being heartless, which is of course, untrue.

Advertisements

2 Comments on “’30 Rock’ goes over the racial edge”

  1. DB says:

    Holy racial oversensitivity. There have been dictators who are mentally unfit for govt of all colors, yep, white too. Cannibalism is not color exclusive, nor is savagery. Idi Amin was personally responsible for a half a million human deaths (up to or more alleged). He stole from, tortured and murdered even his own countrymen. Kim Jong Il not to long ago released a recipe for fried cakes made from stripped corn cobs, and suggested HIS countrymen use it to help supplement a diet of grass. Humans are not able to digest either of these items. Kim Jong Il routinely says things the majority of the world’s people consider outside the bounds of sanity. Americans have not had a leader that has come anywhere near that level of evil or unconcern for their fellow citizens. I’m a knee jerk liberal so I do think the GOP is as a group has done evil deeds, but not to the extent of at least those two dictators. Those two are first dictators, that is why the world knows them. The fact that Amin is Ugandan and Il Korean aren’t the point. You say they are “bad”, past date milk is bad – those two are flat out evil.

    You also miss the point that many humans when confronted w/ a truly horrific situation respond w/ laughter. It seems inappropriate, but It’s just the way we are wired. Yep humans can exhibit stereotypical behavior; remember that word is not always a pejorative. Is it healthier for society to ignore/accept evil to avoid potential racial slurs? Is it healthier to sit and worry about evil until we are mentally and physically unwell? Humans overcome adversity, it’s our thing. It may not be to your liking, but there it is.

  2. Wow says:

    I may be mistaken, but this almost sounds like a pro-North Korean review article on this episode.

    It’s called Patriotism. You can’t be a Patriot (TRUE American) if you don’t find communism ridiculous!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s